Docket Sheet for 05-4222

From: Subject: Docket Sheet for 05-4222 Date: Sun, 26 Nov 2006 10:10:41 -0700 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; type="text/html"; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850" X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.00.2900.2962 This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: text/html; charset="utf-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl?CASENUM=05-4222&puid=01164560897 =EF=BB=BF Docket Sheet for 05-4222

General Docket=20
United=20 States Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit

=09
 Lower court information:

      District: 1088-2 : 2:04-CV-985-PGC
      Ordering Judge: Paul G. Cassell, District Judge
      Court Reporter: Laura Robinson, C.S.R.
      Date Filed: 10/22/04
      Date order/judgment: 8/15/05
      Date NOA filed: 8/22/05
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -=20
 Fee status: paid

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -=20
 Prior cases:
    None
 Current cases:
                  Lead        Member     Start      End
    Companion:
                  05- 4079    05- 4222   8/26/05  =20



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 1  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 LISA BURKE, individually and      Edward T. Wells
 on behalf of all others           [COR LD NTC ret]
 similarly situated                Mel S. Martin
      Plaintiff - Appellant        [COR LD NTC ret]
                                   5282 S. Commerce Dr.
                                   Suite D292
                                   Murray, UT 84107
                                   801/263-1493

                                   Daniel Moquin
                                   FAX 928/283-3158
                                   [COR LD NTC ret]
                                   P.O. Box 725
                                   Tuba City, AZ 86045
                                   928/283-3179

 MICHAEL CARPER, individually      Edward T. Wells
 and on behalf of all others       (See above)
 similarly situated                [COR LD NTC ret]
      Plaintiff - Appellant        Mel S. Martin
                                   (See above)
                                   [COR LD NTC ret]

                                   Daniel Moquin
                                   (See above)
                                   [COR LD NTC ret]


    v.

 UTAH TRANSIT AUTHORITY            Scott A. Hagen
      Defendant - Appellee         [COR NTC ret]
                                   Ray, Quinney & Nebeker
                                   79 South Main Street
                                   Suite 700, P.O. Box 45385
                                   Salt Lake City, UT 84145-0385
                                   801/532-1500

                                   James S. Jardine
                                   [COR NTC ret]
                                   Michael E. Blue
                                   [COR NTC ret]
                                   Ray, Quinney & Nebeker
                                   36 S. State St., #1400
                                   P.O. Box 45385
                                   Salt Lake City, UT 84145-0385
                                   801/532-1500

 JOHN INGLISH, individually        Scott A. Hagen
      Defendant - Appellee         (See above)
                                   [COR NTC ret]

                                   James S. Jardine
                                   (See above)

 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 2  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

                                   [COR NTC ret]
                                   Michael E. Blue
                                   (See above)
                                   [COR NTC ret]

 LOCAL 382 AMALGAMATED TRANSIT     Joseph E. Hatch
 UNION                             [COR LD NTC ret]
      Defendant - Appellee         5295 S. Commerce Drive
                                   Suite #200
                                   Murray, UT 84107
                                   801/268-4042

 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF       Carlie Christensen
 LABOR                             [COR NTC gvt]
      Defendant - Appellee         Office of the United States
                                   Attorney
                                   District of Utah
                                   185 South State Street
                                   Suite 400
                                   Salt Lake City, UT 84111-1506
                                   801/524-5682

                                   Jeffrey D. Kahn
                                   202/616-8474
                                   [COR NTC gvt]
                                   U.S. Dept. of Justice
                                   Federal Programs Branch
                                   20 Massachusetts Ave. NW, Room
                                   7204
                                   Washington, DC 20530
                                   202/353-7633

                                   William Kanter
                                   [COR NTC gvt]
                                   United States Department of
                                   Justice
                                   Civil Division - Appellate
                                   Staff
                                   950 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
                                   Room 7517
                                   Washington, DC 20530-0001
                                   202/514-4575

                                   Robert D. Kamenshine
                                   [COR NTC gvt]
                                   U.S. Department of Justice
                                   950 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
                                   Room 7213
                                   Washington, DC 20530-0001
                                   202/514-2494



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 3  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 LISA BURKE, individually and on behalf of all others
 similarly situated; MICHAEL CARPER, individually and on
 behalf of all others similarly situated,

                Plaintiffs - Appellants,

    v.

 UTAH TRANSIT AUTHORITY; JOHN INGLISH, individually; LOCAL
 382 AMALGAMATED TRANSIT UNION; UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF
 LABOR,

                Defendants - Appellees.



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 4  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 8/26/05           [1840043] Civil case docketed.  Preliminary record =
filed.
                  DATE RECEIVED: 8/25/05 Transcript order form due =
9/12/05
                  for Laura Robinson pursuant to R.42.1. Docketing =
statement
                  due 9/12/05 for Michael Carper, for Lisa Burke.  =
Notice of
                  appearance due 9/12/05 for LABR, for Amalgamated =
Transit,
                  for John Inglish, for Utah Transit Auth., for Michael
                  Carper, for Lisa Burke. (kjs) [05-4222]

 8/26/05           [1840045] Docketing statement filed by Lisa Burke and
                  Michael Carper in 05-4222. Original and 4 copies c/s: =
y.
                  (kjs) [05-4222]

 9/1/05            [1842331] Notice of appearance filed by Michael E. =
Blue,
                  James S. Jardine and Scott A. Hagen as attorneys for =
Utah
                  Transit Auth. and John Inglish in 05-4222.  CERT. OF
                  INTERESTED PARTIES (y/n): y. (kf) [05-4222]

 9/6/05           [1843036] Notice of appearance filed by Joseph E. =
Hatch in
                  05-4222 as attorney for Amalgamated Transit. CERT. OF
                  INTERESTED PARTIES (y/n): n. (va) [05-4222]

 9/9/05            [1843958] Notice of appearance filed by Edward T. =
Wells
                  and Mel S. Martin in 05-4222 as attorneys for Lisa =
Burke
                  and Michael Carper.  CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES =
(y/n): n.
                  (na) [05-4222]

 9/9/05           [1843968] Notice of appearance filed by William Kanter =
and
                  Robert D. Kamenshine in 05-4222 as attorneys for LABR.
                  CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES (y/n): n. (na) [05-4222]

 9/12/05           [1844510] Notice of appearance filed by Daniel Moquin =
in
                  05-4222 as attorney for Lisa Burke and Michael Carper.
                  CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES (y/n): n. (na) [05-4222]

 9/12/05           [1844977] Appellees' motion to consolidate appeals =
and for
                  revised briefing schedule filed by Utah Transit =
Authority
                  and John Inglish. Original and 3 copies. c/s: y. (mt)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/14/05           [1845370] Order filed by PF (dec) denying Appellees'
                  motion to consolidate appeals. The cases will, subject =
to
                  the discretion of the panel, be assigned to the same =
panel
                  for consideration on the merits. [05-4079, 05-4222]
                  Parties served by mail. (mt) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/3/05           [1850578] Appellee's brief filed by Amalgamated =
Transit in
                  05-4079 and 05-4222. Original and 7 copies. c/s: y. =
Served
                  on 9/29/05  Oral Argument? y. Appellant's optional =
reply
                  brief due 10/17/05 for Michael Carper and for Lisa =
Burke in
                  05-4079. (kjs) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/6/05          [1851595] Order filed by Clerk - Transcript order form =
due
                  10/17/05 for Laura Robinson pursuant to Rule 42.  =
Parties
                  served by mail. (na) [05-4222]

 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 5  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al


 10/13/05          [1853643] Notice filed that the transcript was =
ordered
                  previously in appeal 05-4079. Notice due that record =
is
                  complete 10/28/05 for Markus B. Zimmer. (kf)
                  [05-4222]

 10/17/05          [1855150] Filed notice record is complete 10/13/05.
                  Appellant's brief and appendix due 11/22/05 for =
Michael
                  Carper, for Lisa Burke. (pdw) [05-4222]

 10/27/05          [1857782] Errata sheet (for appendix) filed by Lisa =
Burke
                  in 05-4222, Michael Carper in 05-4222.  Original and 2
                  copies. c/s: y (na) [05-4222]

 10/28/05      =
 [1858188] E-Brief received from  Appellants Lisa Burke and
                  Michael Carper in 05-4222. Submission Type: Email. =
(na)
                  [05-4222]

 10/31/05          [1859033] Appellants brief filed by Lisa Burke and =
Michael
                  Carper in 05-4222. Original and 7 copies. c/s: y. =
Served on
                  10/27/05. Oral argument? y., Appendix filed. Original =
and 1
                  appendix copy.  Appendix Pages: 388. Appellees brief =
due
                  11/29/05 for LABR, for Amalgamated Transit, for John
                  Inglish, for Utah Transit Auth.. (kjs) [05-4222]

 11/22/05          [1865041] Appellee's motion to extend time to file
                  appellee's brief until 12/13/05  filed by U.S. Dept. =
of
                  Labor in 05-4222. Original and 3 copies. c/s: y (kf)
                  [05-4222]

 11/22/05          [1865045] Order filed by Clerk granting Appellee's =
motion
                  to extend time to file eres brief [1865041-1] until
                  12/13/05 for U.S. Dept. of Labor (14 day extension).
                  Parties served by mail. (kf) [05-4222]

 11/29/05      =
 [1866648] E-Brief received from Appellees Utah Transit
                  Auth. and John Inglish in 05-4222. Submission Type: =
e-mail.
                  (jc) [05-4222]

 11/29/05      =
 [1866649] E-attachment received from Utah Transit Auth. and
                  John Inglish in 05-4222. Submission type: e-mail. (jc)
                  [05-4222]

 11/29/05         [1868190] E-Brief received from Appellee Amalgamated
                  Transit in 05-4222. Submission Type: e-mail. (jc)
                  [05-4222]

 12/1/05           [1867170] Appellee's brief filed by Utah Transit =
Auth. in
                  05-4222, John Inglish in 05-4222. Original and 7 =
copies.
                  c/s: y. Served on 11/29/05.  Oral Argument? y, =
Appendix
                  filed. Original and 1 appendix copy.  Appendix Pages: =
165.
                  (na) [05-4222]



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 6  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 12/5/05          [1868192] Appellee's brief filed by Amalgamated =
Transit in
                  05-4222. Original and 7 copies. c/s: y. Served on =
11/30/05.
                  Oral Argument? y. (jc) [05-4222]

 12/13/05      =
 [1870195] E-Brief Appellee's brief received from appellee
                  U.S. Dept. of Labor in 05-4222. Submission Type: email =
(kf)
                  [05-4222]

 12/13/05         [1870700] Appellee's brief filed by LABR in 05-4222.
                  Original and 7 copies. c/s: y. Served on 12/12/05. =
Oral
                  Argument? n. Appellants' optional reply brief due =
12/29/05
                  for Michael Carper and Lisa Burke. (jc) [05-4222]

 12/14/05      =
 [1870542] E-Brief Appellants' reply brief received from
                  appellants Lisa Burke and Michael Carper in 05-4222.
                  Submission Type: email (kf) [05-4222]

 12/16/05          [1871394] Appellant's reply brief filed by Lisa Burke =
in
                  and Michael Carper in 05-4222. Original and 7 copies. =
c/s:
                  y (na) [05-4222]

 12/28/05      =
 [1874072] E-Brief Appellant's reply brief received from
                  appellant Lisa Burke in 05-4222.  Submission Type: =
email (kf)
                  [05-4222]

 12/30/05         [1875820] Appellant's reply brief filed by Lisa Burke =
in
                  05-4222, Michael Carper in 05-4222. Original and 7 =
copies.
                  c/s: y. (jc) [05-4222]

 2/15/06          [1889521] Hearing set for May, 2006 Session, at =
Denver,
                  Colorado. (ss) [05-4061 05-4070 05-4079 05-4096 =
05-4131=20
                  05-4222]

 5/10/06          [1916130] Case argued by Daniel Moquin for the =
appellant
                  and Scott A. Hagen, Joseph E. Hatch, Robert D. =
Kamenshine
                  for the appellees, and submitted to Judges Tymkovich,
                  McWilliams, Eagan. (va) [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/1/06           [1951617] Terminated on the Merits after Oral Hearing;
                  Affirmed; Written, Signed, Published. Tymkovich, =
authoring
                  judge; McWilliams; Eagan. [05-4079, 05-4222] Parties =
served
                  by mail on 9/1/06. The district court's dismissal of
                  appellants' claim against DOL, Local 382, and John =
Inglish
                  and its summary judgment for UTA are affirmed; =
Appellant's
                  appeal of the denial of the motion for a preliminary
                  injunction is denied as moot. (at) [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/13/06       =
 [1955217] Other E-document received from Appellee, Local
                  382 Amalgamated Transit Union in 05-4079 and in =
05-4222.
                  Pleading type: Bill of Costs.   Submission type: email =
(kf)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 7  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 9/14/06           [1955422] Bill of costs filed by Appellee Amalgamated
                  Transit in 05-4079 and 05-4222. Original and 3 copies. =
c/s:
                  y. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/15/06       =
 [1955992] Other E-document received from Lisa Burke and
                  Michael Carper in 05-4079, 05-4222. Pleading type: =
Petition
                  for En Banc Rehearing. Submission type: Email. (na)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/20/06           [1957006] Order filed by Judges Tymkovich, =
McWilliams,
                  Eagan - Response to Appellant's Petition for Rehearing =
En
                  Banc due 10/5/06 for Amalgamated Transit and Utah =
Auth. in
                  05-4079, for LABR, Amalgamated Transit, John Inglish =
and
                  Utah Transit Auth. in 05-4222.  Parties served by =
mail. (na)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/20/06           [1957264] Petition for rehearing in banc [05-4079,
                  05-4222] filed by Lisa Burke and Michael Carper in =
05-4079
                  and 05-4222. Original and 18 copies. c/s: y. (lab)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/20/06           [1957279] Document [1957264-1] Petition for rehearing =
in
                  banc filed by Appellants Lisa Burke and Michael Carper =
in
                  05-4079 and 05-4222 submitted to panel. (lab)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/23/06       =
 [1958241] Other E-document received from Lisa Burke and
                  Michael Carper in 05-4079 and 05-4222. Pleading type:
                  Objection to Awarding of Costs and Request for Stay.
                  Submission type: email. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/27/06           [1959423] Appellant's response (Objection to Awarding =
of
                  Costs and Request for Stay) filed by Lisa Burke and =
Michael
                  Carper in 05-4079 and 05-4222. Original and 3 copies. =
c/s:
                  y. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 9/28/06       =
 [1960205] E-Motion (Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
                  in which to file Response to Petition for Rehearing)
                  received from LABR in 05-4222. Submission type: email. =
(lab)
                  [05-4222]

 10/2/06           [1960626] Appellee's motion to to extend time to file
                  petition for rehearing until 10/19/06 [05-4222] filed =
by
                  LABR in 05-4222 and submitted to court. (na)
                  [05-4222]

 10/4/06       =
 [1961853] Other E-document received from Utah Transit
                  Auth. in 05-4079 and 05-4222 and John Inglish in =
05-4222.
                  Pleading type: Opposition to Petition for Rehearing En
                  Banc. Submission type: email. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 8  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 10/4/06       =
 [1961858] E-attachment to Opposition to Petition for
                  Rehearing received from Utah Transit Auth. in 05-4079 =
and
                  05-4222 and John Inglish in 05-4222. Submission type:
                  email. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/5/06           [1962077] Order filed by Judges Tymkovich, =
McWilliams,
                  Eagan granting Appellee's motion to extend time to =
file
                  response to petition for rehearing [1960626-1] in  =
05-4079
                  and 05-4222. Parties served by mail. (na) [05-4079 =
05-4222]

 10/5/06       =
 [1962341] Other E-document received from Amalgamated
                  Transit in 05-4079 and 05-4222. Pleading type: =
Opposition
                  to Petition for Rehearing. Submission type: email. =
(lab)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/6/06          [1962675] Appellees' response in opposition to =
appellants'
                  petition for en banc rehearing filed by Utah Transit =
Auth.
                  and John Inglish in 05-4222 and in 05-4079. Original =
and 18
                  copies. c/s: y. (kf) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/6/06           [1962678] Appellees' response to the en banc petition =
for
                  rehearing filed by Utah Transit Auth. and John Inglish =
in
                  05-4222 and in 05-4079 [1962675-1] submitted to the =
court.
                  (kf) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/10/06          [1963180] Appellee's response (Opposition to =
Appellant's
                  Petition for En Banc Review) filed by Amalgamated =
Transit
                  in 05-4079 and 05-4222 Original and 19 copies. c/s: y. =
(lab)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/10/06          [1963187] Appellee's response filed by Amalgamated =
Transit
                  in 05-4079 and 05-4222 [1963180-1] (Opposition to
                  Appellant's Petition fo En Banc Review) submitted to =
court.
                  (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/18/06      =
 [1966272] Other E-document received from LABR in 05-4079,
                  LABR in 05-4222.  Pleading type: Response to Petition =
for
                  Rehearing En Banc.   Submission type: Email. (na)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]

 10/19/06          [1966523] Appellee's response filed by LABR in =
05-4222
                  Petition for rehearing in banc and submitted to court.
                  Original and 18 copies. c/s: y. (pdw) [05-4222]

 11/6/06           [1971992] Order filed by Judges Tymkovich, McWilliams =
and
                  Eagan denying Petition for rehearing in banc =
[1957264-1] in
                  05-4079 and 05-4222. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 11/7/06           [1972576] Bill of costs submitted to court. (lab)
                  [05-4079 05-4222]



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 9  =20



 Proceedings include all events.
 05-4222  Burke, et al v. Utah Transit Auth., et al

 11/7/06          [1972578] Document [1959423-1] Appellant's response
                  (Objection to Awarding of Costs and Request for Stay) =
filed
                  by Appellants Lisa Burke and Michael Carper in 05-4079 =
and
                  05-4222 submitted to court. (lab) [05-4079 05-4222]

 11/8/06           [1972634] Order filed by Judges Tymkovich, McWilliams =
and
                  Eagan granting bill of costs [1955422-1] in 05-4079 =
and
                  05-4222. Parties served by mail. (lab) [05-4079 =
05-4222]

 11/14/06          [1974101] Mandate issued. (na) [05-4079 05-4222]



 Docket as of November 14, 2006 8:04 pm               Page 10  =20



PACER Service =
Center
Transaction =
Receipt
11/26/2006 =
10:08:39
PACER Login: lb1628 Client Code: 
Description: dkt report Case Number: 05-4222
Billable Pages: 10 Cost: 0.80

= ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: image/gif Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/images/btnHome.gif R0lGODlhRgAUAPYAABAYEFpmUpChmbG5qTlSOdra2oCIeykpIWt7ZtLS0sLCwv///zNCKRgpGKGh mUpSQuvr65CZiHN7czlCOaGxoUpmSiEhGGZrWlpzWrm5sePr44iZiIiQiCk5KczSzHuIexgYGFpr UpmhmbHCsbG5sUJSOePj2trj2oiQgICQgICIgCkzIXOAa2t7a9La0szMwsLMwjlCMzNKMzNCMyEp GKGpmVJaSkpaQkpSSvPz85mhkJChkJCZkHuAc3OAc0JKOTlKOamxoVJmSiEhIWtzZmZzWsLCubnC ubm5uTM5KRghGFprWpmpmUJaQkJSQuPj4ykzKczMzDlKMyEzISEpIaGpoUpaSnuAe0JKQqm5qamx qVJrUlJmUmZzZjM5MwAAAPf/OLzx1VRQTAAAAgAAAAAAAXJlbGJlV2VnYUM2XG5JIG5yZVNcdGNy dW1pXHNlZ3RuYmVtb2ZpZwKrMMQSTd8R8QPYsN1AAAPxkAAAEgAAAgAAAAAAAfe5tmW6WP///yH5 BAAAAAAALAAAAABGABQAQAf/gFUkVUwihoeGPIo7OxGLO4+KPBwcjhERlI47OjqGTJOaIjwRO4kc PCKEiYwfXU47VSIfVlY3Tje2TUJCXFxWCTkuLgknCwZWGgVcHwsiQsAfQQseHC4FSxwLPlYwEL20 XEIlDwFLXEtWQCUhLUBUSlSsXD8T9RNAQDETM/z8Xv/9ZvzzAmTCvyReZnRAaLADFChAnNSLkdBL h35JZujTiG+flxVKlEzhoUULkxAVeAlJ2QslrQQJlgixwoyDkBsVnETcYo7Wkp/minRp0WJoF5Zb uiDoUoSLkxIEuvhggeGcOypQeFSpwiFEiC2+rFSoQGvsrwQYzDH7wCWHEaE5/zIQKZCB1oIWDHZ4 cKIjB4cPJO4WIRsupxVfTpwcBjvjHZUqUTwc0bJ1aw0RNWJV1lylZCwmm0WhqgJrKwXPWUoa0hKE QpCSWkgMEhE7NYVYH5oY1FolgtclIVb6KnGjhJMtCVxw4Zntw8wbPthacVLUR9cuf7t0OWe9i5AQ VraE+BkigK8b+JYctdJYCRTMIjgoRifFSZEbQpYUMSfMF4EWC0jQwwLACVGFC0S44IBOC3DQgggJ ILfAhBPOktItQIBjzjn7WQGFEgAoQRJXvIQQFhdNiDWTFURVANUyvXQRTRUtmHMBDrS0wEVURBzG BW1MyKRYeLw4cU44KtWSxP87K+iIBRTvhEQFFQeEJCU88FigJTyOOWallFNiGeYQ75DJJRUWgDnl lBasKaUWHrxAQmol3bYVaFuxRtlrWlAAGmuxiFCIAKlsthllqMBGAZ1BaEbCCLA1ykML6ImAhAIk YELJppx2uqmmnX4gaqc7MMEEJqSMMkolpXQyCSWofPKXEDM8pBUFEXBRwTe0TOciAb8o14sBCzin YU+HCXVOF0tg4OwSFZho5HJAhWCDEzGso1RTITQ2RFZV1NCViSvx0sSQ38H0FRfE2vRBDhMqgxy8 C5zwxIQDtBCCCxPm4INTVgiRVsA/zSQFsOpN4JgIFMR3jnjmKIbBeEI44UL/MMIU0wOAEhwWhQtL uHCEFV00iMAAykVxwl8iLNCSWQTcwIUNz5kDhG5UkKnDVhwEPJyRYvUyU3K1OCFBsT5o08sRMblQ hS8BOsGDB1y4AEMLLAz1DVnTgZMTcVx8FYNjWjHRMy22lEAcLSqpO9NaIbRsQg7+duGCFjEHKEMN HhAQAt33HsEFTlaY6NQ5u4Rtzg0dSKmVCD2AM/hhvIQlVrSSJyaWeGBN5wRZBAiRYgk+frcETyGk aPk5PptYSwfvTBEBWxNAscKUD92+JhW3n7k77lCGqQQNWAW/5grET9n77sHbrvuaIIBwABc4NMb8 Q1ZihdUUKzz0O/JKNBDSGO3dPzTFQ7ZTMcXx3AP/UBLnoy//AVAEAgA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: image/gif Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/images/btnPACER.gif R0lGODlhRgAUAPYAABAYEGZrZqmxqTlSOdra0pCZiCkpIXuIe7m5uf///3OAc1JaSuvr6zNCKczS zBgpGGZ7ZqGpmcLCwlJrUjlCOSEhGGtza6m5qUpSQuPr4+Pj45mpmZChmSk5KYiQgHN7a0pmShgY GGtzZmZzWkJSOdrj2tra2pmhkJChkJCZkCkzIYCIe7nCsXuAc1pmUlJmSvPz8zlCMzNCM9LSzCEp GGt7ZqmxoaGxoaGpoczMwsLMwlprUkJKOTlKOSEhIbG5sUpaQkpSSpmhmTM5KYiZiIiQiHOAaxgh GGZzZkJaQkJSQikzKYCQgICIgLnCuXuAe1JmUjlKM9La0tLS0iEzISEpIWt7a8zMzFpzWlprWkJK QrHCsUpaSjM5M7zx1QAAAPf/OLzx1VRQTAAAAgAAAAAAAXJlbGJlV2VnYUM2XG5JIG5yZVNcdGNy dW1pXHNlZ3RuYkVDQWlnLgKrAMQSTd8R8QPYiNzwAAPxkAAAEgAAAgAAALzxEAAAEAAAIGgxECH5 BAAAAAAALAAAAABGABQAQAf/gDg/OBtChoeGKYooKAWLKI+KKUVFjgUFlI4oJyeGG5OaQikFKIlF KUKEiYwHSEooOEIHXFxASkC2SS9TJQcHHgwlUB4JIigJWT1WCQcvL1BQI0g7UjAlJlJTFlwRCQI2 AlMJHi8kGC5ZUFlcPSQ7Vj1VR1WsUDwU+BQ9PTEUMv//uggEKENglx4UBA7pIqPDwoQdlizpoQRf DIZdOgAcIqNfx33+uqg4coRKCgECNuwA8ewFS2hSEsiE4QTJCy4vEkh5AQSEkh4KGMicYiVLlpgy ZZpA8iNpAgZOaiAZAUUJiQFIFBjBoi5elSUpcOAosmPHBCi0QIDgMmXKWi4g/7DoYLBWnbcRAhII EaHgSgIkXBxcaUARlxUnCSCMGEHMhkslXNAqgQzlrAx5VXBcceBEgFixEYREiPWZNA6UsTaUFoUK ByyxN1BfQGno2w1wKH8MEiLgx+wbsQ4kSRgWR4GyWXa4REtiigMlE140nZBFwhUYQtgBucKgKpcD CVBwkUIgCxIk6qDkfbGDywQGOpK7QAtkn/m1l48sES3EA+R1USgxAhAvSKGBB76gxwUMTpXAXgJk ieACCQqoI4UJPQAxARcycIFDAlC8gJh/9dGSnjojrLPEEQAccdJYz+yAVmRJcPHBB7Sk9QFaN0Gh QDMgQMGbEAHQoowVB/x4gP8VXBhRRBYvQDbCCukokZ4zIdYyhDwqWAGFFkvIQ1IVVRhA0pjzzFPB mvNghtmZY5KZppw+yFNnm1VUECeZZFbA55gCOJCDbygJAJxYqon1jWe43aDaN7EIUQgHqZRWmmeo FHrDbJCm8sMWhdqAQwpW1CcEAhL8UIAHrLbqQRGvwsqqrJXIGiuCvszKKgobbIAJKaOMUkkpnaTQ KiqfIPiCDBKFdUMBUAQ5Iy1KTJFBKnldAU0RMgEWGXglOAIDA+hJwUChAggBQl44gOOXEMktoEQM 7iBRA1U7XOYDWDhEQJaMLj2TRLVTsPfCh2fBgIMDJSghQwMJpOAeFEkUgMT/UVLsgIQVO6SY11mQ wbfOC0bdFMUAXJhHAWZC3NCfOhPsUCUXWCA1kwITOFFCZOEpAd4KMp+V8lEwSGE0UVnc4BQMHqw1 ABBQLHATEOn0MFwVdZ4glgc4MWclXFPsZOJ3EP6YVzpQpedCAjhAMcMMHViJlhUsJCAjFAx0xwVk kflEAtRmxYBZWBtwTYstJPzN1hRZcrEDDAJ0TQ0D6ZTwlEwp2OKAUwnMsENTVPU0BQxVqoOlzFAA 0cGYYQnRgompR/bMtGq1F1lVkIEQs9CTOf1CjSTczl4W1O1Q47TqSE5fB/JQUcABUFCwhApkSkQ9 n1VQjyf21Ycp5xE0fOU9P58qhE+m9th7P/31fIYQggFQBHFZ+hKd+dVXVKggEfflH/EASdTTn0So IJHpVYEK5Mtf9yQyBAIW8IEGWEIgAAA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: image/gif Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/images/btnOpinions.gif R0lGODlhRgAUAPYAABAYEGZrWqmxqTlSOdra0pCZiCkpIXuIe8LCwvPz82tza1JaSjNCKRgpGOPj 46GhmczSzFJrUjlCOSEhGGZ7ZrGxqUpSSpmpmZChmSk5KYiQgHuAc3OAa6GxobHCsbm5uUpmShgY GGtzZmZzWmZrZqm5qUJSOePj2trj2tra2pmhkJChkJCZkCkzIYCIe8zMwsLMwv///3N7a2t7a1pa UlJmSjlCMzNCMyEpGOvr4+Pr46GpmdLSzFprUkJKOTlKOSEhIWt7Zrm5sbG5qbGxsUpaQpmhmTM5 KYiZiIiQiHuAe3OAc6mxobnCsRghGGZzZkJaQkJSQikzKYCQgICIgMzMzHN7c1JmUjlKMyEzISEp Ievr66GpodLa0tLS0lpzWlprWkJKQrG5sUpaSjM5M7nCuXJlbGJlV2VnYUM2XG5JIG5yZVNcdGNy dW1pXHNlZ3RuYm5pcHNub2ZpZ8QSTd8R8dzQAAPYeAPY6AAAEgAAAgAAALzxEAAAEAAAIGgxECH5 BAAAAAAALAAAAABGABQAQAf/gFxiXBdGhoeGLIorKwWLK4+KLElJjgUFlI4rKiqGF5OaRiwFK4lJ LEaEiYwHT1ErXEYHY2NFUUVeEFA1NVdXW0xjMVtgMjErYxBGY10JVlYJAiMEXU8wCRpPKV5jOzEs YCjcAihjCjEaV2BjPyY9Mz9aTlqsVz4S+BI/PzYSN///yMQgAfAGmYM/JBw8QuZGBoYKM0iR8iMK PhsNyWQAeORGP4/7/JFp4cRJFhYCBFzoAaJXDRBgysSIkYALrRpgaozB2aOGFy5RKkYAc4VWly5g iI54MmMG0yctr0R4EuTJiCtRTAx4soTDF3XxtEhhwYVLkh49IhTtkQBFjzEy/9qOARGjyxVjLK54 kdZFABgRKYSM8eLlBxEHUaLAyDGjTAoKI4Zwq+IFRBQUAsYkHiP1yg15WrhUgVBGQNmyO4zsiHWa NZeUsS60FoWKC6yyHWCXSGlIAJMOTFIKEDPIyPDdHWIdgKKQLJcCaMH0ZIHORBETAmI86XFghAYN Pa7UmHGlyBKmS66AuLJhRo8nYDQkSXplRisNMyL0APNEg4uiRezDHwhjfOaEFKoZoUEUY6yDBQRd FIHTCGDE4FcMSwzwAwQ8DMZEDz/1IEIXD0QB4RcxGFFEBEvEMAYXPIjHhRe8eDGTF/SpQ+EYUjgB gBMomdVLeLSoU5YRb9GCjv8h61xxAAU1yDADUQFYMMYMAYyxVVkHFDEGBy7kBMYMY0RwgGkHEMWL eLUcIU8L5IUhhTwlaaGFASXVOc88E/Q5D2ig5VmnnXsSCoQ8h/6pxQSD2mnnBI7WKQAEL4ixW0rJ lSVbWb6ZFpwAHcjmWyxGFIJBKq21ZhoqwnVwKROsieGBcLCyMEOARnyAgBgFfOfrd0nIFyywwGLi KyUaHKAssRqscMEFmJAyyiiVlNIJC76i8kmyNdwwEVkdFKCeL7SgEAMXB8AQgxhjhOdLBGrVMIS4 9BU5Qhli8AfGF/yCAUJ4UbyblHQLRGGDO1Rd1cNnQIzFxQ5nhfdSGVtAweD/GE+kKEwCM7nlkxEM VMExTWAUcdQIM5hLU5oCJDCyBjUcMPIJIuiExQANPiEBaEZ0oKA6+oHRBQxjfLFfDTwIcEUMOxTl RQWD2dRFGfv1xUwXI6RQxlfUgdFBDEUJ0AUIXCRgRAAzLKBTEUT9wJwWh6pQlgY7FWXCCjGw5IsG 6CydRGJelHFFF1wMXrjQhXvRRRQpsBAw3zM00UV4AlR2xQgilM2EZdZdkZYNoJF1Ad202GKCBhyb m4AMSsaAQlvSdVGC0AI88URfA+QSBRgJ6KBDDAf0IEYKV804RhKup4DOmvuVl0GdZBmxQZHlcdZL UbSAQNf0vmwGgn5qaRYFe4ED1ADFGCZwJt5+Q/VwPvacrTMkgBnIk0UBB1whgRQt2DlR/47SQv+c QAMyBNBRE4mUE3AgljkFsAUMtNMAA+hA/gHQUSEIgQGuYIHPUHAieRKLWLLQggQ+EAdOaEBJ+lfC iWRhIvzTQhYc1QIS+g+GR3ghDHdoACkEAgA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: image/gif Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/images/btnHelp.gif R0lGODlhRgAUAPYAABAYEFpmUpChmbG5qTlSOdra2nuAcykpIdLS0lpzWsLCwv///5CZiDNCKRgp GKGpmUpSQuvr64CQgGtzZjlCOUpmSiEhGLm5uePr44CIgCk5KdLSzMzSzKGxoWuAa3N7cxgYGGZr WlprUpmhmbm5sbHCsbG5sUJSOePj49rj2oCIe3uIe3uAeykzIdLa0mZzWszMwsLMwpmhkJChkJCZ kDlCMzNKMzNCMyEpGKGpoVJaSkpaQkpSSvPz84iQgGt7ZkJKOTlKOVJmSiEhIbnCuTM5KamxoXOA axghGFprWpmpmUJaQkJSQikzKWZ7ZmZzZszMzDlKMyEzISEpIUpaSoiZiIiQiGt7a0JKQlJrUlJm UjM5M6m5qamxqXOAcwAAAPf/OLzx1VRQTAAAAgAAAAAAAXJlbGJlV2VnYUM2XG5JIG5yZVNcdGNy dW1pXHNlZ3RuYnBsZWZpZwKrMMQSTd8R8QPY6N2wAAPxkAAAEgAAAgAAALzxEAAAEAAAIGgxECH5 BAAAAAAALAAAAABGABQAQAf/gDkmOUojhoeGNIozMwyLM4+KNFZWjgwMlI4zMjKGSpOaIzQMM4lW NCOEiYwrT0wzOSMrVFQ7TDu2S0JCWlpUQlRJWgg9Li4IBQsGWhEpSV4LI08uJl5EyloYRCdMvb5U WkInEAHCSVRBJyJXQVNIU6xaQBT0FEFBNRQ3+/tb/vw3/G0JQsFfkS03NBwsSANKkyBM6NVAuEUD vyI38mW8p29LCyRIpNDo0kWJiAq8hKDsdZLWryRCECBIIkIItA8QswijlcRFF2Evnly5IvTJyixP fjx5oYXJCQJPvBxJoCVJuylNaOTIYUWEiCzfKlSgJZZsgp4IwGlZsUBCkh4c/yZ4iUCECoIRDWb0 qFUAwQoPTl68GBuuAhNwVJgc1gL2hrspOaBwINJl69YHIx7Esrw5B8lYSjiLQpUD1tYOn7mQNNTF SAcjJLuYGDRCtuoOsVYsYbiVgVeaKn2d2MEtixARjI0hF8LWizcvXipoEYGgS1QvKlb8qApTBJUs IpLQDOBrx70kRqk4RtIk8wgJh89FYfJih5AkL4RV9cWBAzcqbEnA1gIELoBAED5dkUoWVEywgGHh UIHSLUHQsl9V+VHRBBIAIDESV7wgZ+ESEgLjUgUnCAWMFleskIR0EnQxAg+0hJAEATkUUNs56MF0 2He8dCPMLhHuUIQ7LVyhBf8WTbgD0hRTHADSk++8Y8GV7zz22JRPQlmll0O4E2aWU1jQJZRQWoDm k11wAIMJqpGE21ahbdVaZbB10UForcUyQiECpMIZZ5WhElsHcRqxmQklxKYoDVeYN8IFCpjAgASY ZuqDFZty6oMEnIKKCaadCrjCCp9agekMSiiBCSmjjFJJKZ3Q8KkEqHwioBA3NJFVDh0woIV039DC BIoE0IKcFsaAxdwCLu4ETlA+PZFEAti+iFw3jIlHkw5M1KBOUkyJ4NgQvz7Q1XIrLfHjccB8ZQxw 0DxxQwg9EIjADj1x8UIXKBDYwxVZFNzUL2e9BBMVUSSLHgWPjdDBe1WBJ8z/YQmEJwS3yfUgEzLQ JrFAF5imEEO/PwzgQi859LAiOCeNRcAOWugADL9aBLHbFGHKsJUEvwjXjYS9mFjeBhzQrIUK0ELj IovnuJADEzSQwHIPR9DUi4TGWmjYcNNlUcNjWikBNC22nDAcLSkpGxMCIUrQlhY0LIBCBD1osQMH OdjwwAI94O3FUEztMNayQhIZnt4aPKnVCAZYqDc4vBQrlndqKSYheGAldiwVBAixRA4cqHVcEjqJ QGKxVQUt4g4auCMFAytoQUETLUDpa+5oTpE7mb3r3qSXSOCAVZMU8ABlC8Yvr6XuurfAO5oggHCA Fjw41ruvGz7ZZBNStOBrHvDMI+EASLmL76sU3OcuBZothC+8r0Wwz/39BzQRCAA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850 Content-Type: image/gif Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Location: http://pacer.ca10.uscourts.gov/images/pdficon.gif R0lGODdhFgAYAKIAAP///+7u7t0AAAICAgAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACwAAAAAFgAYAAADZji63K4gyknn qpiGC54PG9RJYjeQIHdC62oOqXhGrEvHc1vWcJh7DlwERBQEjMSkb5gUOJVJDvQJFQKmyKpUacwq t8WmMwsGIcdnK3dcJIvE1ejb7I1L2XH57MjPE+91eRdAhIWGCQA7 ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C71143.209E8850--

PACER Service = Center
Transaction = Receipt
11/26/2006 = 10:08:39
PACER Login:	lb1628	Client Code:
Description:	dkt report	Case Number:	05-4222
Billable Pages:	10	Cost:	0.80